Digital Empire

Questions You Should be Asking the World Around You

Good News Today. Federal District Judge Rules Against CNN’s Attempt to Dismiss Defamation Case.


As far as I can tell, this goes all the way back to February of 2016.  A surgeon from St. Mary’s hospital, Dr. Michael Black, sued CNN for defamation after CNN led a malicious campaign against the hospital’s pediatric cardiac surgery program.

One of the major grab lines CNN used was that Dr.Black received up to $500k per surgery, even though Dr.Black was a salaried employee, and that the hospital’s two year budget was $876k.

CNN presented their news piece in such a way that it pitted the hospital’s surgery ward against the “extremely poor” stereotype. How typical.

It also appears that CNN used a crisis actor to fan the flames. CNN had an employee go around inside of the hospital with a fraudulenty obtained visitor’s pass to trash talk the nurses while CNN was piecing the article together.

The lawsuits states Robinson contacted patients and nurses, telling them that Black “kills babies” and leaves them “butchered” and “mangled.” She also held herself out to be a CNN employee and the lawsuit confirms that Robinson was the stranger who appears in the lead of CNN’s print story, warning a couple in the elevator to have their heart-sick infant transferred from St. Mary’s.

Here is the feb 2016 article from Mypalmbeachpost.


http://www.mypalmbeachpost .com/news/mary-surgeon-sues-cnn-jupiter-farms-heart-mom/8znpWlieY9S5lwB2izx65J/

That’s Dr.Black’s lawsuit.

St.Mary’s former CEO David Carbone also filed a lawsuit against CNN; I’m guessing this is in addition to Dr.Black’s lawsuit. Fast forward exactly one year after Dr.Black’s lawsuit, Federal District Judge Orinda Evans rules that Carbone’s defamation case can move forward.  CNN’s attempt to have the case dismissed was denied.

Judge Evans didn’t mince words in her 18-page order allowing the case to move forward, and dismissing CNN’s attempt to get it thrown out of court.

Carbone’s argument was that CNN skewed their statistics in order to sensationalize a news piece.  Carbone’s attorney offered a statement to LawNewz:

“In our case, we contended that CNN essentially made up its own standard in order to conduct an ‘apples to oranges’ comparison to support its false assertion that St. Mary’s mortality rate was 3 times higher than the national average. Accordingly, the case against CNN certainly fits the description of media-created ‘Fake News.’”

http://lawnewz .com/uncategorized/hospital-ceo-wins-major-court-ruling-after-accusing-cnn-of-false-reporting/

This appears to be the legal David M. Carbone v. Cable News Network document. Filed Feb 15, 2017.




Thoughts, comments, suggestions? Feel free to leave a reply. You may need to sign in to Wordpress. Or you can leave your e-mail address. (Replies are moderated)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on 02/27/2017 by in NA and tagged , , , , , .

Questions You Should be Asking the World Around You

Everything and nothing specific

See something you like?

Send a request, and I'll try and get you your own custom Digital Empire art.


February 2017
« Jan   Mar »
Follow Digital Empire on

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 385 other followers


the road less traveled


Klea Qafa


Exposing Truth

Willy7799's Blog

Just another site

Which Television?

More TV Choices

Martial Arts Weapons and Training

Weapons and Training Equipment for All Martial Arts Enthusiasts

Seven Spheres

Aqua Terra Ignis et Aer

The Flying Tofu

Japan . Travel . Food


Banker. Blogger. Mother. Wife.

Frederic Sealey

Frederic Sealey is an American entrepreneur and investor with an extensive experience in capital investment, commercial real estate development and venture capital management. carl frederic sealey


comedy magazine

Le paradis de Noémie

les pieds dans l'eau


comedy magazine

%d bloggers like this: